Community
No ratings yet
Sign up and review 3 courses to unlock your For You Score.
Shelter Island sits between the two forks of Long Island's East End, reachable only by ferry — a short crossing that immediately signals you've left the mainland rush behind. Gardiners Bay Country Club occupies this unhurried island setting, where the surrounding waters shape everything from the light to the wind, and where golf has long been part of a slower, more deliberate summer rhythm. The club takes its name from Gardiners Bay, the broad body of water separating Shelter Island from the North Fork, and the connection to place feels genuine rather than merely decorative.
As a private country club on a small island community, the atmosphere here is rooted in the membership — familiar faces, low-key competition, and a course that rewards local knowledge over raw power. A par 70 layout suggests a design that leans on strategy and shot-making rather than length, asking players to be precise rather than simply long.
Shelter Island draws a loyal summer crowd of East End regulars and those willing to take both ferries to reach it. If you're playing Gardiners Bay, chances are you already know exactly why you made the trip.
| Tee | Yards | Rating | Slope | Par |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blue · men | 6,460 | 71.9 | 131 | 70 |
| Blue · women | 6,460 | 77.4 | 137 | 71 |
| Blue / White · men | 6,335 | 71.3 | 130 | 70 |
| White · men | 6,140 | 70.1 | 129 | 70 |
| White · women | 6,124 | 75.5 | 136 | 71 |
| White / Gold · men | 5,775 | 68.4 | 125 | 70 |
| Gold · women | 5,460 | 71.8 | 123 | 71 |
| White / Gold · women | 5,460 | 73.6 | 132 | 71 |
| Gold · men | 5,436 | 66.8 | 120 | 70 |
| Red · women | 5,341 | 70.9 | 122 | 71 |
| Silver · men | 3,950 | 60 | 104 | 70 |
| Silver · women | 3,950 | 63.1 | 106 | 71 |
No scores yet
Be the first to log a round here.
