Cherry Valley Club

Garden City itself is something of a shrine to American golf history — Cherry Valley's neighbor, Garden City Golf Club, hosted some of the sport's earliest major championships, and the corridor along Stewart Avenue has long been regarded as one of the richer concentrations of classic course design within reach of New York City. Playing golf here means stepping into a lineage, even if Cherry Valley operates quietly outside the spotlight.

The terrain across this part of Long Island is relatively flat but open to the persistent winds off the Atlantic, which routinely turn a composed round into something that demands real course management and shot-making discipline.